cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Community Tip - You can Bookmark boards, posts or articles that you'd like to access again easily! X

Creo Parametric Community Challenge August 2023 - Archimedes Screw

DaveMartin
16-Pearl

Creo Parametric Community Challenge August 2023 - Archimedes Screw

DaveMartin_0-1690898510166.jpeg

 

The Archimedes screw is a water pump that allows water to be raised from a lower to higher elevation. It consists of a central shaft with a helical surface, which itself sits within a cylindrical channel. Your challenge, should you choose to accept it, is as follows:

  • Design an assembly for the Archimedes screw capable of lifting water a vertical height of 1.5 meters. The assembly should contain at least one mechanism connection. Your Archimedes screw does not have to resemble those in any of the images here.
  • It can be either hand-operated or motor-driven. (The motor can be represented by a simple box part model.)
  • Create a rendered image of your model.
  • (Optional) Create a Kinematic Analysis using the Mechanism Design Extension (MDX) and output a movie of the playback. Note that every license of Creo Parametric comes with MDX.
  • (Optional) Create a rendered animation of the motion using the Design Animation Option (DAO). Every license of Creo Parametric comes with DAO.

In your submission, please indicate the version of Creo Parametric that you used to create your model.

 

This challenge was inspired by an Archimedes screw on display at the Pacific Science Center in Seattle:

DaveMartin_1-1690898510194.jpeg

 

DaveMartin_2-1690898510218.jpeg

 

           

DaveMartin_3-1690898510242.jpeg

 

Please submit a zip file of your submission as a reply to this post. If you choose to submit an assembly file only (no rendered image, rendered animation, or kinematic analysis movie), don’t forget to embed the components.

The submission period will end on Friday, September 8th.

Find the PTC Creo Community Challenge Guidelines here!

 

Dave Martin - dmartin@creowindchill.com - https://www.mcaeconsulting.com
27 REPLIES 27

Inspiration...

ascrewfeeder.png

Interesting. Can you share your files?

Dave Martin - dmartin@creowindchill.com - https://www.mcaeconsulting.com
kdirth
20-Turquoise
(To:DaveMartin)

I am going to be brave and be the first to post a model.  Whil not quite complete, (no hardware and other finishing touches) here is what I created:

kdirth_0-1691509177389.png

Creo 7.0 files attached.

 


There is always more to learn in Creo.

Congratulations! You are the first person to submit a model of a solution!

 

 

Dave Martin - dmartin@creowindchill.com - https://www.mcaeconsulting.com
Michael
12-Amethyst
(To:DaveMartin)

render.pngdrawing.png

Michael P Bourque
Boston Regional User Group

Hi, Michael. Do you want to post your files so you can be considered along with the rest of the submissions?

 

Thanks,

Dave

 

 

Dave Martin - dmartin@creowindchill.com - https://www.mcaeconsulting.com
Manuelito
6-Contributor
(To:DaveMartin)

Still need to figure out why the renderer adds the speckles...

archimedes.jpg

Real time rendering works fine

archimedes_screenshot.png

Patriot_1776
22-Sapphire II
(To:Manuelito)

I'd be more worried about the fact that rendering it either way put a big bend in the middle of the screw....🤣

I consider this correct light breaking at the surface of the water 😁

Patriot_1776
22-Sapphire II
(To:Manuelito)

It is, the difference between the reflective/refractive/light transmissibility of air vs water, just busting yer chops.  🤣

I think if you use "denoise" and wait a bit the speckles should go away.

Manuelito
6-Contributor
(To:DaveMartin)

Please find attached the Creo files for the previous thread. The zip file also includes a simple MDX animation (rendered version still has speckles, it seems as "Denoise" works in real time rendering only....)

 

Have fun!

Dear PTC Community,


Hope you are doing well !
Thank you for arranging this activity, Here is my attempt to complete this challenge.
It's kind of "Eureka" moment for me to post the solution. (I don't literally mean 😁 like what Archimedes said to world by uttering "Eureka" back in ancient time) 
This design is attempted to complete in basic mechanical design manner, which is followed in industry, can be considered as purely a concept design only and it is inspired to use "PTC Creo Parametric" basic and some special modules, ex. AFX/IFX., Render Studio & Mechanism Design/Design Animations. During this design, some machine elements like Bearings, couplings and Motor has been used as step files derived from common platforms like McMaster-Carr  and manufactures online CAD-configurators (for electric motor & bearing) Selection & modeling of auxiliary components, geometry size is for visual purpose only, that does not involve any calculated results (except a 1.5-meter lift height as parameter to consider while modeling) 

Whereas creating rendered video which is posted above was little challenging in the absence of recommended & supported GPU memory. 
Overall assignment in this challenge also gives further task to understand the options used in detail. It was great learning experience.  

Creo Parametric 9.0.4.0 version is used in this activity.

Rendering-1Rendering-1Rendering-2Rendering-2







 

 

screenshot1.pngscreenshot2.png





Posting CAD files and one non-rendered animation for reference in this post  

Everyone, in light of end of summer vacations, Labor Day, and kids going back to school, we have decided to extend the contest through Thursday, September 14th. If you still want in on the contest, please take a couple hours to create a submission and post it here.

 

Good luck and happy modeling!

 

Dave Martin - dmartin@creowindchill.com - https://www.mcaeconsulting.com

Here is my submission although it is not compete. I used Creo 10. 

 
kdirth
20-Turquoise
(To:AS_10152878)

Got a screenshot for those of use not lucky enough to work on the latest version of Creo?


There is always more to learn in Creo.
AS_10152878
4-Participant
(To:kdirth)

xtop_r20ySkoeXp.png

Here is a screenshot.

It looks like the individual piece parts are missing. Can you try zipping up another file? Otherwise, you can embed the components. Thanks!

 

Dave Martin - dmartin@creowindchill.com - https://www.mcaeconsulting.com

I embedded the component. 

I used Creo 8.0 to build this model.

 

-Tom McGuire

Thanks to everyone for participating. The challenge is now closed.

 

I am writing up the results. If you submitted an entry and would like me to use your real name instead of your PTC Community username, please send me a message through here.

 

We just happened to make a visit to the Pacific Science Center today. Here's another picture of their Archimedes screw. It's capable of conveying a surprising amount of water (if you spin it fast, which Ellie can't).

 

Elliott.jpeg

 

 

Dave Martin - dmartin@creowindchill.com - https://www.mcaeconsulting.com

Hi Dave,

You can use my name.

Alexandru

Manuelito
6-Contributor
(To:DaveMartin)

Hi Dave

 

you can use my name

 

Manuel

Thanks to everyone who participated in the inaugural Creo Community Challenge (and shoutout to Dave for leading our Creo Challenges)! Participant badges have been delivered to all who submitted!

 

Dave's solutions blog is now live on ptc.com: https://www.ptc.com/en/blogs/cad/creo-community-challenge-august-2023-archimedes-screw

 

Challenge 02: Isogrids is now live and submissions are open through the first week of November. Give it a try!

Top Tags