cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Community Tip - Visit the PTCooler (the community lounge) to get to know your fellow community members and check out some of Dale's Friday Humor posts! X

Family table option when replacing Extern Copy Geometry source

Family table option when replacing Extern Copy Geometry source

To improve the top-down design methodology when designing variations based uppon a skeleton that's a family table, we'd like to suggest this improvement.
Youtube unlisted video:

 

This is the setup:

Kristof_D_0-1643294685754.png

A skeleton that contains a family table with the refs for a 3/4/5m machine, those refs are packed in a publish geometry.

Kristof_D_1-1643294738400.png

That Published geometry is taken in with an external copy geometry and used in different features.

Kristof_D_2-1643294773507.png

When saved to a new variant for 3Meter machine.

Kristof_D_3-1643294790903.png

And the skeleton is renamed as well.

Kristof_D_4-1643294806458.png

It's still looking at the original skeleton source for 4 meter.

Kristof_D_5-1643294865068.png

We can do an edit definition and point to the source of the instance of 3 Meter, which has the same feature numbers and ID's.

Kristof_D_6-1643294914221.png

But Creo doesn't treat the family table part as the same or connected, and all features fail:

Kristof_D_7-1643294949463.png

So if there could be an option to replace the source parameter to a family table member, retaining the feature number and ID's, that would save a lot of time rebuilding all the dependent features.

 

Please mind this old idea , showing that it's somewhat possible if the machines would be a family table as well, though mind that a good advice for family tables is that the instances should somehow be 90-95% the same construction. It's no use having 3/4/5 meter variations of assemblies in a family table when they contain a lot of different parts.

Replace External Copy Geometry By Instance - PTC Community

 

Please mind that the demo-files are made in creo 7.0.6

 

3 Comments
olivierlp
Community Manager

Hello, 

Thank you for your idea and the information provided.

olivierlp
Community Manager
Status changed to: Acknowledged
 
mwa
13-Aquamarine
13-Aquamarine

Maybe when using  Rename in session instead of Save as can solve your issue