cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

Newbie

CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

I hear PTC marketing talk about how CREO will have the Microsoft Ribbon interface. But I have to ask....is it the true microsoft native ribbon interface code / objects, etc. or is PTC doing the their usual thing of mimicking the true microsoft components but via their own toolkit GUI. Yes, I know that PTC is a microsoft partner, etc. but that doesn't mean that porting the windows components to toolkit or java is good thing. The PTC GUI seems to be hampered by the toolkit vs. what can be done in native windows / ,NET, etc.

I would concede that it used to be the other way around, but...

Somone could cite the need for PTC to be platform independent, but being dependant on the windows OS hasn't exactly hurt solidworks, has it? I suppose some hope to run PTC on apple someday, but not sure that your IT department or even leaders of your company are going to be willing to switch you over to apple.

I think the larger point is that I hope CREO GUI is gonna be great. By great I mean that it has to be as good or better than solidworks and inventor's latest gui's. It is hard to imagine that PTC can match what these two are doing unless they "go native".

I could be wrong on this, but really it is going to take a PTC dev person to set me straight, not a marketing person

18 REPLIES 18

Re: CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

Unless the migration to the Windows interface was completed in WF6 the marketing people AND users will be seriously disappointed with CREO.

Wildfire was supposed to see the migration of ProE to a Windows interface. Even at WF5 it is majorily incomplete - drawing is still riddled with menu manager and it was "rewritten". Lets hope it was completed in WF6 so CREO has a decent platform to move forward.

The introduction of the Ribbon interface in drawing has caused a major stir amoungst users - it shows a lot of promise but PTC need to get involved with experienced users and make it work smoothly. And they need to do this in WF5 because its likely to turn into a weeping sore if they leave it as is in CREO. I cant believe PTC are so poor at this - its not like writing a stable solid modelling kernal - even little companies can write wonderful interfaces.

I suspect the root of the problem lies with no one at PTC using their own product - all manager managers and kpi's. Can anyone at PTC turn out 50 drawings in a month - their product would be radically different if they had to.

Highlighted

Re: CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

As far as I understand, the root of the problem (and the tragedy of PTC) is that many years ago (at the end of 80s) the development of Pro/E was started on the Sun Solaris platform and until now this is the main development platform of the Pro/E team. Consequently, all the UI elements are hand-made for Solaris and ported to Windows - they are not a Windows native controls.

With such an approach there is no chance to obtain modern nice looking Windows interface. And, frankly speaking, it is not an easy problem to resolve, when the whole R&D is organized in the UNIX environment of Sun Solaris. This is the tragedy of the company with the glorious past, which dosn't allow them to move fast to the future.

At the end of 80s Sun Solaris was, perhaps, the only platform for developing 3D CAD - Windows was in its childhood (16-bit system with a poor graphics), while Solaris was already solid 32-bit graphics workstation. But now!... Sun is already dead and the future of Solaris is dark, while Windows 7 is the powerful system with the perfect graphics. Does PTC want to continue development on Solaris with the further porting to Windows?...

Actually, now it seems to be too late to think about moving from Solaris to Windows (SolidWorks did this brave step nearly 20 years ago and they were the winners). Now the agenda should be different. What about moving away from the desktop Windows applications to the web-based cloud applications? What about moving CAD to Windows Azure? To my mind, this is the mainstream of the software development for the next decade...

Re: CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

I find this discussion interesting and true. I can't believe how long it has taken to transition to a "windows like" environment, and it still isn't complete. It is sort of a running laugh among power users here.

It is hard to explain to my new users why certain commands revert to drop down menus, and how to navigate through them. In some ways it seems like the transition should have never started since the "old" way of drop down menus worked pretty darn good.

Re: CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

Maybe I am an idiot, but when I saw the CREO event. I originally though that CREO 1.0 was a brand new CAD software developed from the ground up by PTC for the Windows platform.


If this is not the case, I will be very disappointed. The UI and ease of use for Wildfire is terrible. We are in the 5th generation of Wildfire and the UI is still incomplete and the code is still based on some Unix.

When in modeling mode, you have two different UI's to deal with depending on what you are doing. You have the Wildfire UI and the Pro/E 2001 UI. You switch to drawing mode and you are now in a 3rd UI. It's like working with 3 different software tools.


We have core features that are still not converted to the Wildfire UI and some major usability issues all around. Wildfire needs to be distinguished and PTC needs to write new software from the ground up to compete with others in this space.

I can't get a straight answer from anyone at PTC about CREO 1.0

IS CREO 1.0 a new CAD software built from the ground up that can read the native Pro/E files of today or is it just another upgrade with the same code underneath?

It seems no one can answer that question. My hopes are that CREO is a brand new start with a modern engine for the Windows environment. They can toss everything up to this point in the fire (Pun intended) and give us something worth our maintenance dollars. Apple did this with OS X and it worked out great for them. I can only hope PTC does the same with CREO 1.0

If anyone can answer this question with a straight forward Yes or No, please let me know. It's not a difficult question and the answer is simply Yes, CREO is a brand new engine built for the Windows environment or NO, CREO is simply the next version of Wildfire with a new name.

Sorry if I sound frustrated but the truth is that I am.

Re: CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

Only PTC know what will be presented going forward

Frankly the upgrade path doesnt make much sense for the customer - there seems no point in upgrading to WF5 let alone CREO 1.0 and probably not the first version of CREO 2.0. That route will only be for the brave.

I cant understand the point of CREO1.0 - maybe its just WF6.

If PTC recycle menu manager and WF they will be left with a legacy WF4 customer base.

Re: CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

If CREO 1.0 is nothing more than WF6 rebranded. I will do everything in my power as the CAD Manager to move us and all our partners away from PTC and purchase SolidWorks.

I am sick and tired of half baked software when we pay good maintenance money.


CREO 1.0 needs to be a new CAD Software built from the gound up with native Windows code if PTC plans on competing with SolidWorks.

Re: CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

If you were at the PTC conference last summer you were able to get a initial look at the next major release of Pro/E not to be referred to as Wildfire 6. It was essentially creo 1.0 pre production.

Creo is a 2 decade strategy of evolving the current Pro/ENGINEER into the future. It also gives PTC the chance to market the standalone (Pro)Co/Create to the existing customer base with the promise of eventually being part of the unified system.

I doesn't hurt to investigate alternatives. Even Inventor is starting to look like a doable thing.

Joe

Re: CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

Joe,


Thanks for the great information.


I have one question.

How do you evolve a CAD System into. the future when you never finished the initual eveloution from Pro/E 2001?

I will leave it at that or this can get ugly quick.

Re: CREO: true Windows Ribbon interface or "looks like Windows Ribbon Interface"

Agree.