cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Community Tip - Have a PTC product question you need answered fast? Chances are someone has asked it before. Learn about the community search. X

Translate the entire conversation x

Solve for "a" symbolically, MC11

SFares
14-Alexandrite

Solve for "a" symbolically, MC11

Hello All,

 

How do I solve for "a" symollically? "a" represents the maximum cantilever length. (0.125) is the maximum deflection in inches at the end of "a". I have attached MC11 sheet.

SFares_1-1764173706104.png

 

SFares_0-1764173513022.png

Regards,

Sam

ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
Werner_E
25-Diamond I
(To:SFares)

Prime is able to solve your fourth order equation but its not able to display the result because it feels that its too large to display.

Werner_E_0-1764178736326.png

But you can assign the result a function in the four input arguments.

Once these arguments have values assigned you can evaluate this function. You will get all four solutions. Prime can't know if the results are real or not or which are positive or negative without knowing specific values for w1,E,I and L.

Werner_E_3-1764179494100.png

 

But I wonder why you would bother with symbolic calculations at all. If at the end you are just looking for numeric results its better to use Prime's numeric facilities - like the "root" function:

Werner_E_2-1764178992762.png

 

 

View solution in original post

5 REPLIES 5
Werner_E
25-Diamond I
(To:SFares)

Prime is able to solve your fourth order equation but its not able to display the result because it feels that its too large to display.

Werner_E_0-1764178736326.png

But you can assign the result a function in the four input arguments.

Once these arguments have values assigned you can evaluate this function. You will get all four solutions. Prime can't know if the results are real or not or which are positive or negative without knowing specific values for w1,E,I and L.

Werner_E_3-1764179494100.png

 

But I wonder why you would bother with symbolic calculations at all. If at the end you are just looking for numeric results its better to use Prime's numeric facilities - like the "root" function:

Werner_E_2-1764178992762.png

 

 

SFares
14-Alexandrite
(To:Werner_E)

Thank you Werner for providing different  options. How did you get a_solution function to evaluate?

SFares_0-1764183272693.png

Regards,
Sam

Werner_E
25-Diamond I
(To:SFares)


@SFares wrote:

Thank you Werner for providing different  options. How did you get a_solution function to evaluate?


First I tried with "simplify" but I cancelled the operation because it took too long. Without "simplify" it finished within a reasonable time.

SFares
14-Alexandrite
(To:Werner_E)

Hello Werner,

When I tried the following,  I get the message bad solve.  Am I doing something wrong?I have MC 11.0.1.

SFares_1-1764596069485.png

 

Regards,

Sam

 

Werner_E
25-Diamond I
(To:SFares)

"Bad solve variable" usually means that the variable was already assigned a value.

You can clear the variable completely by using   clear(a)    or clear its just for symbolic use by typing    clear.sym(a).

 

Generally the assignment of the symbolic "solve" to a function is better done in front before any variables are defied.

 

Announcements

Top Tags