cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Community Tip - Learn all about PTC Community Badges. Engage with PTC and see how many you can earn! X

Calculate the Theat for a invers quartic potential

WalterSchrabmai
7-Bedrock

Calculate the Theat for a invers quartic potential

HI friends,

I am looking to get the solution for a Tetha for a quatrics potential from these equations:

(Reference: Classical Mechanics by Herbert Goldstein 1980 2nd ed.)

I have a potential  

 

V(r) = const / r^4.

 

Can anyone here help me with a MathCAD 15 Sheet, how to do it?

Thanks

Walter

 

 

Goldstein_1.jpgGoldstein_2.jpg

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions

It's not completely impossible:

LM_20190226_Theta0.png

But then there is WolframAlpha:

LM_20190226_Theta1.png

Now the biggest hurdle may be to have Mathcad calculate the function F, the elliptic integral of the first kind...

 

Success!
Luc

View solution in original post

13 REPLIES 13

Hi,

 

Enclosed are functions.  Is this what you want?

 

Cheers

Terry

Thanks a lot, but I need a symbolically solution for that.

I can not do it.

What Could I do?

best

 

It's not completely impossible:

LM_20190226_Theta0.png

But then there is WolframAlpha:

LM_20190226_Theta1.png

Now the biggest hurdle may be to have Mathcad calculate the function F, the elliptic integral of the first kind...

 

Success!
Luc

Great! Thanks a lot!
Best regards
Walter

I have found this sheet for elliptic integrals....but its MMA! Never kind, thanks a lot.

 

http://functions.wolfram.com/EllipticIntegrals/EllipticK/introductions/CompleteEllipticIntegrals/ShowAll.html

You mean 'Mixed Mathematical Arts'?

It's not that bad. In Mathcad 11 its available in the symbolic processor (Maple):

LM_20190227_F0.png

 

Do you happen to have a set of numerical values for E, l, m and R ?

I might be able to get you a plot of Theta versus r

 

Luc

Thanks Luc,

I have realized that the limits must be chosen carefully to get a real theta angle.

Although the analytical solution is fine, it could be done also numerically.

demo.jpg

Certainly, that's possible.

Be careful to choose your parameter values then, and inspect the integrand before the numerical integration. In your case, no wonder you got an imaginary result:

LM_20190227_Theta0.png

I had to move the values quite substantially to allow r to go/start near 0:

LM_20190227_Theta1.png

Success!
Luc

Awesome! Great! Thanks a lot.

Hi

Can anyone here tell me why in teh free SMath Studio there is a other/wrong solution?

 

SMath.GIF

The upper limit on your inset diagram is e not b.  If you change b in SMath to 0.11 you get 0.007 (to three decimal places).  

 

Alan

Thanks a lot!

Great!

Top Tags