cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Cone, plane, ellipse

SOLVED
Highlighted
Emerald IV

Cone, plane, ellipse

I know a and b of an ellipse. What is the value alpha of a circular cone?

Cone.png

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
Highlighted

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse

Yes,

N.png

here is example when a=15, b=8 and alpha=30 degree...

N2.png

..and when alpha changes to 40 degree

Observe that auxiliary view is normal to cutting plane and does not show real cone angle.

View solution in original post

11 REPLIES 11

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse

a & b are not sufficient to define alpha.

No mather what alpha you have, you can allways slice cone to obtain ellipse with dimmensions a & b.

/Avdo

Highlighted

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse

Thanks!

For a of a circular cone too?

Highlighted

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse

Yes,

N.png

here is example when a=15, b=8 and alpha=30 degree...

N2.png

..and when alpha changes to 40 degree

Observe that auxiliary view is normal to cutting plane and does not show real cone angle.

View solution in original post

Highlighted

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse

Thanks!

I suspected it. But I always want to check!

When I was in school, I drew something around 1000 triangles, measured their angles and made sure that their sum is 200 degrees.

Just kidding! 180 degrees!

Highlighted

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse

Nice,

 

Now: is it possible to prove, or dis-prove, that one of the two focal points of the ellipse lies on the axis of the cone?

 

Luc

Highlighted

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse

Fine idea!

Add condition of the problem!

One of the two focal points of the ellipse lies on the axis of the cone.

PS

New year tree for our problem

tree.png

 

Highlighted

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse


@ValeryOchkov wrote:

Fine idea!

Add condition of the problem!

One of the two focal points of the ellipse lies on the axis of the cone.


Mission impossible (if we still are talking about a circular cone).

The focal points are where the Dandelin spheres touch the plane.

-> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dandelin_spheres

 

Highlighted

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse

Theoretically there is one trivial solution to the problem!

One focus is on the axis if other focus is on axis too 🙂 lol

observe that circle is only special variant of the ellipse when a=b=r

otherwise it is allways offset from cone axis to the focal points.

/Avdo

Highlighted

Re: Cone, plane, ellipse


@ptc-5737066 wrote:

...

otherwise it is allways offset from cone axis to the focal points.

Which needs to be proved.

One way to do so is by the Dandelin spheres - if of them should touch the plane in a point on the axis, the plane has to be horizontal and the intersection is a circle.

You sure know that the center of the ellipse is not on the axis as well (unless in the case of a circle).

 

Announcements