cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Mathcad Prime 3 solver block

Highlighted
Newbie

Mathcad Prime 3 solver block

I'm slightly confused, can any one see why this will not solve.  I have 4 equations and 4 unknowns.

link is attached below.

any help would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you in advance.

I have tried putting all the static values in the guess values

https://www.dropbox.com/s/eh8hesqd5t0z9v1/T50047%20Tractor%20imposed%20loads.mcdx?dl=0

6 REPLIES 6

Re: Mathcad Prime 3 solver block

Hi David,

Please attach your Mathcad Prime worksheet (but without pictures in the document) to the message ("Use advanced editor" --> "Attach").

Re: Mathcad Prime 3 solver block

File attached now

I looked for that option when I was posting before

Thank you

Re: Mathcad Prime 3 solver block

It perhaps can't find an equality because there isn't one.  I replaced find with minerr and your equations appear to be quite sensitive to initial conditions.

Stuart

Re: Mathcad Prime 3 solver block

Strange that it cant find an answer as the truck is driving down the road. 

the answer above does not satisfy the first equation

R1+R2+R3+R4=A1+A2+A3+A4+KP

In the real world I would expect to see the majority of the load imposed from Kp to be in R3 and R4

Re: Mathcad Prime 3 solver block

David Callaghan wrote:

Strange that it cant find an answer as the truck is driving down the road. 

All I can suggest you do is get that truck off the road immediately.  Operated a vehicle not in accordance with the laws of physics is a contravention of the Road Traffic Act and liable for 3 penalty points and a fine not exceeding £250!


the answer above does not satisfy the first equation

R1+R2+R3+R4=A1+A2+A3+A4+KP

In the real world I would expect to see the majority of the load imposed from Kp to be in R3 and R4

I did a bit of rearranging, putting the inequalities into functions and checked the case where KP = 0 kg ... I'm guessing this should make R = A?  If so, then the expressions for r1 and r4 may need a closer look.

Stuart

Re: Mathcad Prime 3 solver block

StuartBruff wrote:

David Callaghan wrote:

Strange that it cant find an answer as the truck is driving down the road. 

All I can suggest you do is get that truck off the road immediately.  Operated a vehicle not in accordance with the laws of physics is a contravention of the Road Traffic Act and liable for 3 penalty points and a fine not exceeding £250!


the answer above does not satisfy the first equation

R1+R2+R3+R4=A1+A2+A3+A4+KP

In the real world I would expect to see the majority of the load imposed from Kp to be in R3 and R4

I did a bit of rearranging, putting the inequalities into functions and checked the case where KP = 0 kg ... I'm guessing this should make R = A?  If so, then the expressions for r1 and r4 may need a closer look.

Stuart

Found the problem.  In the expression for balancing about R1, the A terms are parenthetically grouped, but they are subtracted not added inside the parentheses.  In the expression for R4, L2 appears twice in the A1 term, not L3.  Correcting the expressions allows find to do what it says on the label.

Stuart