cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Partially filled pipe flow

SOLVED
Highlighted
Newbie

Partially filled pipe flow

I constructed the attached worksheet for partially full open channel flow in a pipe using the Manning's and Colebrook-White equation, the problem is that the calculation proceeds as would be expected if the pipe diameter is 2 m but if one changes the diameter to be small or bigger than 2 m (change the highlighted yellow value) then the whole calculation gives very unexpected results and in some cases division by zero errors. Can some of the more learned users examine this worksheet and explain to me why this is the case?

Thanking you in advance.

Kind regards, Mark Buckton

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions

Re: Partially filled pipe flow

In your definition of wetted area function P_w(r,d) in the d>r sectionyou had

P_full as 2 pi m - s_arc

should have been

2 pi r - s_arc

Mathcad was taking m as meter, so when r = 1 the equation worked

View solution in original post

5 REPLIES 5

Re: Partially filled pipe flow

Re: Partially filled pipe flow

See please (the red formula) how we can work with empirical formulas!

Re: Partially filled pipe flow

Valery

Thank you for this insight, I was not aware of this work around for empirical formulas hense why I have given the normally unitless Manning's n units of m^-1/3/sec^-1. I will file your suggestion for later use. However this workaround does not answer the specific problem i.e. why does the answer "blow up" (as seen in the graphs) for pipe diameter values less than or bigger that 2m.

Mark

Re: Partially filled pipe flow

In your definition of wetted area function P_w(r,d) in the d>r sectionyou had

P_full as 2 pi m - s_arc

should have been

2 pi r - s_arc

Mathcad was taking m as meter, so when r = 1 the equation worked

View solution in original post

Re: Partially filled pipe flow

Thank you f.kohlhepp this change has corrected the problem.

kind regards, Mark

Announcements