cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Community Tip - Learn all about PTC Community Badges. Engage with PTC and see how many you can earn! X

The problem with boxes - 1, 5, 21...

ValeryOchkov
24-Ruby IV

The problem with boxes - 1, 5, 21...

We cut out from one square sheet (cardboard), four small squares and make a cross-shaped piece out of the box. Then we cut out of four small square sheets sixteen more small squares and make them into new boxes and so on to infinity. What will be the maximum amount of an infinite number of boxes?http://twt.mpei.ac.ru/ochkov/Mathcad_12/3_09_5_Box.png

11 REPLIES 11

One solution for a one box:

http://twt.mpei.ac.ru/ochkov/Mathcad_12/3_08_Box.png

I think the total volume is given by V=a(1-2a)^2/(1-4a^3), where the value of 'a' to give maximum volume is 0.174 and the corresponding value of V is 0.076.

See attached.

Alan

Thanks, Alan!

What can you say about this solution:

http://twt.mpei.ac.ru/ochkov/Mathcad_12/3_10_N_Box.png

Interesting recursive relation for 'a'. Can't see where this particular one comes from! No real need for intermediate results here of course; just set 'a' to be the same on both sides and solve for a to get the infinite recursion value immediately.

Alan

AlanStevens wrote:

Interesting recursive relation for 'a'. Can't see where this particular one comes from!

I can't see too

One reader of first my book on Mathcad (see the Preface >>>) has sent me this solution without any description (may de he was legendary Tom Gutman )

And other same problem! How many cones with max sum volumes we can do from one circle workpiece?

3Cone.png

Here's a "starter for ten". Numerical only. I've assumed each segment angle bears same relationship to what remains as first segment angle bears to whole cirlce. I haven't proved that this leads to the maximum volume (it might not!).

Alan

Cone1.PNG

Cone2.PNG

AlanStevens wrote:

Here's a "starter for ten".

Ten!?

Sorry, Alan!

I think we can have only two cones with max sum volume.

The sum volume is less with 3-d cone!

http://twt.mpei.ac.ru/ochkov/Mathcad_12/3_06_3_Bucket_TriPlot.png

Yes, the infinite cone assumption is easily outmatched here.

Alan

PS The phrase, "starter for ten", comes from a quiz show in which contestants have to answer a "starter" question that gives them 10 points if they answer correctly.

AlanStevens wrote:

PS The phrase, "starter for ten", comes from a quiz show ...

OK!

We say in Russia in same case "dance from the oven"!

I've figured out where the recursion relation for the boxes comes from:

BoxRecursion.PNG

Alan

Thanks, Tom Gutman

And what about cones from the round workpiece?!

Top Tags