cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Units are not compatible

SOLVED
Highlighted
Guest

Units are not compatible

I'm trying to create a calc where the answer is a design factor. The calc works fine when just using numbers, but when I try to use a value from earlier in the sheet I get the 'units are not compatible message'. Would appreciate any help on this, thanks.

Capture.JPG

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
Highlighted

Re: Units are not compatible

You need to give the 50 units also:

 

units.PNG

 

Alan

 

View solution in original post

8 REPLIES 8
Highlighted

Re: Units are not compatible

1.4 is a dimensionless quantity

a similar question

Highlighted

Re: Units are not compatible

You need to give the 50 units also:

 

units.PNG

 

Alan

 

View solution in original post

Highlighted

Re: Units are not compatible

This is the biiiiiiig old problem of "designed equations" from diverse textbooks or scriptums for example. A really big Problem

You have to check out first, which dimension the variable Df must have.

The parameter 1.4 must have the same unit like Df.

If 0.6 is a uitless factor then ok, but the 50 must have the unit of Unit(Tdt)*Unit(Df)²

 

 

Volker
Highlighted

Re: Units are not compatible

If you combine the two solutions: first and second, you can find a way to formalize the empirical expressions

изображение.png

Tags (1)
Highlighted

Re: Units are not compatible


@vlehner wrote:

This is the biiiiiiig old problem of "designed equations" from diverse textbooks or scriptums for example. A really big Problem

You have to check out first, which dimension the variable Df must have.

The parameter 1.4 must have the same unit like Df.

If 0.6 is a uitless factor then ok, but the 50 must have the unit of Unit(Tdt)*Unit(Df)²

 

 


True.  But, in my experience, design factors are usually dimensionless.

 

Alan

Highlighted

Re: Units are not compatible

Thanks everyone, I've got it working now. All the replies are appreciated 🙂

Highlighted

Re: Units are not compatible


@AlanStevens wrote:


True.  But, in my experience, design factors are usually dimensionless.

 

Alan


Many of these "design factors" are unit conversions

Highlighted

Re: Units are not compatible


@Fred_Kohlhepp wrote:

@AlanStevens wrote:


True.  But, in my experience, design factors are usually dimensionless.

 

Alan


Many of these "design factors" are unit conversions


Yes, though these are usually supplied as single numbers rather than expressions that require evaluating, are they not?

 

Alan

 

Announcements