cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Understanding patterning of a standard hole with point patterns

Highlighted
Tanzanite

Understanding patterning of a standard hole with point patterns

Covers point patterns of standard holes and the use of Alternate Origin as a best practice to correctly generate the pattern.

 

1 REPLY 1
Highlighted

Re: Understanding patterning of a standard hole with point patterns

Good presentation, though I feel you didn't completely explain why when using holes the revolve feature causes things to be different than extrude feature (don't they both produce "cylindrical" objects???), but anyway, I think the better question would be why does PTC accept that the "best practice" is to have to do more useless work of picking the alternate origin point which has already been picked when the hole was placed on it!

Even worse, the software design often leads to modeling mistakes which are not caught because visually, the error is often not apparent - as your video nicely demonstrates.

At the very least, the system should warn the user that "pattern instances closely overlap - perhaps a different alternate origin needs to be used".

But really, why can't it be that if the feature being patterned is using a point in a "pattern-sketch" as a reference, then that very point should be selected, by default, as the "alternate origin"  This has already been requested:

Point pattern with standard holes - fix it

However, instead of choosing to improving the user experience, PTC has no plans to fix this - as apparently, this "works according to specification".

Announcements