Community Tip - Your Friends List is a way to easily have access to the community members that you interact with the most! X
(This is only a puzzle to fun! )
Tokoro.
All distances of the points to be Integer
Solved! Go to Solution.
Hi,
I found the lengths 4,6,4,6,4 by trial and error until I got integer results for the diagonals.
Regards
Terry
Hi,
I'll play (The definition does not need the radius be an integer?)
@LucMeekes wrote:
You are not free on the radius. Because the diagonals are twice the radius. Hence radius must be an integer times 1/2.
Which diagonal of which pentagram must be a diameter of the circle? There may be a solution where one diagonal or maybe even one side of the pentagon is a diameter but sure not necessarily.
Even with four points its not demanded to be a regular quadrilateral or to have any symmetries. Its just the solution shown which happens to be at least a rectangle. And I see no proof that 5/2 is the minimum for the radius in case of a quadrilateral.
I have no clue how to proof that the solution for 4 points shown really is the minimum (wrt the radius) and that not maybe an irregular quadrilateral would not lead to a smaller radius.
Nor have I any idea how to use Mathcad to help finding any solution with 5 points, let alone the minimum one.
Its clear that it suffices to demand for all distances to be rational as we then can blow up the figure as necessary to make them integer, but I don't think that knowing this is much of help.
I stand corrected.
Luc
@terryhendicott wrote:
Hi,
I'll play (The definition does not need the radius be an integer?)
Correct, but I guess you overlooked that ALL distances of any two points must be integer. This includes the diagonals which in case of your pentagon are not integer.
Thanks Werner
thought it was too easy
Cheers
Thanks for your time to fun! Your answer is correct for 3 points.
By the way, connect all n points on the circle is good programing exercise for the students.
Hi,
Have an answer for 5 pointed problem.
Sides are 4,6,4,6,4 in a 4.131182 radius circle.
Diagonals are 8,8,8,7,8 all integers.
Calculation sheet enclosed.
It is based on solution of intersection of two circles one centred at origin and radius R, the other centred at R,0 with radius equal to side length.
Starting with next side, place a circle of radius the length of the side and centre at last location obtain the intersection point.
Repeat this for each side.
This is repeated around the circle to get a closing angle that should equal 2 pi.
Manually ratio the closing angle to 2 pi to get the next starting radius. Just do this till maximum accuracy is obtained
Cheers Terry
To be exact, that radius is 16/sqrt(15).
Luc
Great Solution!
But how do you get the side lengths 4,6,4,6,4 ?
Once you have decided that the sides should be of that lengths, the radius can easily be found using symbolic solve:
Hi,
I found the lengths 4,6,4,6,4 by trial and error until I got integer results for the diagonals.
Regards
Terry
This answer of n=8 is r=
It is very large and the shape is not smart. So, the best answer should be more small.
Mathcad Prime 6.0 sheet. n=8
n=9
I find a new point of No.14. So the r reduced to
This calculation also limited by 15 digits, It is about 100 points on the circle. May be from 2 to 5 points are the best solutions.
Find the new 4 points answer.
Answers of n=4 to 13. No.5 is find by terryhendicott.
New stab series (red line) reduces to only 7% at 50 points.
(3663075,0) (-3663075,0)
(3649821,311328) (-3649821,311328) (-3649821,-311328) (3649821,-311328)
(341859,3647088) (-341859,3647088) (-341859,-3647088) (341859,-3647088)
(3596925,693000) (-3596925,693000) (-3596925,-693000) (3596925,-693000)
(723075,3591000) (-723075,3591000) (-723075,-3591000) (723075,-3591000)
(1025661,3516552) (-1025661,3516552) (-1025661,-3516552) (1025661,-3516552)
(3491709,1107288) (-3491709,1107288) (-3491709,-1107288) (3491709,-1107288)
(1672419,3259008) (-1672419,3259008) (-1672419,-3259008) (1672419,-3259008)
(3244899,1699632) (-3244899,1699632) (-3244899,-1699632) (3244899,-1699632)
(3219171,1747872) (-3219171,1747872) (-3219171,-1747872) (3219171,-1747872)
(1774749,3204432) (-1774749,3204432) (-1774749,-3204432) (1774749,-3204432)
(2040675,3042000) (-2040675,3042000) (-2040675,-3042000) (2040675,-3042000)
(2348931,2810808) (-2348931,2810808) (-2348931,-2810808) (2348931,-2810808)
By H. Fujiwara.
Today, Suzuki find the new smallest answer for n=5 to 18.
n=5 The answer is.
[r 0],7,5,3,5,3.
n=6. Same r and add and [r 0],5,3,5,3,5,3.