cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Community Tip - New to the community? Learn how to post a question and get help from PTC and industry experts! X

"These units are not compatible"

JLand0299
4-Participant

"These units are not compatible"

Screenshot (356).png

 

I always run into this problem. I don't know why

ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
Werner_E
25-Diamond I
(To:JLand0299)


@JLand0299 wrote:

I was just told by my instructor that this particular problem can not be done in MathCad. Due to the fact that the actual unit for C_l and C_s needs to be Btu/ (lbm*F) or something like that. He just told me to add values without units for just a numerical answer. I do see where I need to add the multiplication to the formula. 

 


I am pretty sure that this problem CAN be done in Mathcad and even in Prime. You just have to use Delta °F instead of just °F. Temperature units are a bit tricky - if you want to be on the simple and safe side you may consider using K throughout.

But there still is a unit mismatch in the first summand - there's missing lb or lbm in the denominator.

I added it the bold way in the following screenshot but you'll have to check the formula or the units assigned:

B.png

 

View solution in original post

4 REPLIES 4
Werner_E
25-Diamond I
(To:JLand0299)

Can't you see that every of your three summands has different units? You simply can't add quantities of different dimensions!

Furthermore you are missing a multiplication sign between C.l and the parenthesis. Without that multiplication sign Prime assumes a function C.l with T.p-T-m as argument.

B.png

 

JLand0299
4-Participant
(To:Werner_E)

I was just told by my instructor that this particular problem can not be done in MathCad. Due to the fact that the actual unit for C_l and C_s needs to be Btu/ (lbm*F) or something like that. He just told me to add values without units for just a numerical answer. I do see where I need to add the multiplication to the formula. 

Screenshot (361)_LI.jpg

Werner_E
25-Diamond I
(To:JLand0299)


@JLand0299 wrote:

I was just told by my instructor that this particular problem can not be done in MathCad. Due to the fact that the actual unit for C_l and C_s needs to be Btu/ (lbm*F) or something like that. He just told me to add values without units for just a numerical answer. I do see where I need to add the multiplication to the formula. 

 


I am pretty sure that this problem CAN be done in Mathcad and even in Prime. You just have to use Delta °F instead of just °F. Temperature units are a bit tricky - if you want to be on the simple and safe side you may consider using K throughout.

But there still is a unit mismatch in the first summand - there's missing lb or lbm in the denominator.

I added it the bold way in the following screenshot but you'll have to check the formula or the units assigned:

B.png

 

JLand0299
4-Participant
(To:Werner_E)

Thank you sir for all your help. I appreciate your knowledge and I will pass along what I had learned.  

Announcements

Top Tags