Solved: Re: Prevent building structure through Creo Parame...

slapha · ‎Sep 08, 2020

Is there a parameter you can add in a Creo Parametric assembly that, when owner associated, will prevent the product structure from being built automatically?

I have memory of seeing this mentioned somewhere, but cannot find any references to it. It might have also been a product enhancement idea, or mentioned at LIveworx/Tech Committees.

There are Windchill preferences to prevent creation of parts, and use gathering parts. You can also use Contributing Image which has similar results.

Tdaugherty · ‎Sep 15, 2020

Here are a few scenarios that might clear things up.

New Part (WTpart desired)

Create new part
Set EFBOM parameter to NO (In CAD)
Check In

Result: The CAD file is checked in. A WTpart is built on check in.

New Part (WTpart not desired)

Create new part
Set EFBOM parameter to YES (In CAD)
Check In

Result: The CAD file is checked in. A WTpart is not built on check in.

New part assembled into assembly (WTpart desired)

Create a new part
Set EFBOM parameter to NO (In CAD)
Assemble the component into another assembly
Check in the component and the parent assembly

Result: The CAD file is checked in. A WTpart is built on check in and it is added to the parent assembly's structure.

New part assembled into assembly (WTpart not desired)

Create a new part
Set EFBOM to parameter YES (In CAD)
Assemble the component into another assembly
Check In the component and the parent assembly

Result: The CAD file is checked in. A WTpart is not built and nothing is added to the parent assembly's structure.

New assembly containing new components (WTpart(s) desired) - video attached

Create a new assembly containing new components
Set EFBOM parameter to NO (In CAD) at the assembly level
Check in the assembly and its components

Result: The CAD files are checked in. A WTpart is created for the assembly. Each assembly component is evaluated individually. If EFBOM is set to NO, a WTpart is not created.

New assembly containing new components (WTpart(s) not desired)

Create a new assembly containing new components
Set EFBOM parameter to YES (In CAD) at the assembly level
Check in the assembly and its components

Result: The CAD files are checked in. A WTpart is not built for the assembly. None of the subcomponents are evaluated because the assembly was not set to build.

I hope this helps! There are some other nuances that I didn't mention but this should give you a general idea of how we use this functionality.

Ty

View solution in original post

Tdaugherty · ‎Sep 08, 2020

Hi,

We use the EFBOM attribute for both Creo and SolidWorks. Here's what I was able to dig up. It's in the SolidWorks section of the Windchill documentation but we do use the same attribute for Creo. EFBOM acts as a switch that controls build participation during checkin.

https://support.ptc.com/help/wnc/r11.2.0.0/en/index.html#page/Windchill_Help_Center/WWGMSWAdvTechSolidExcludeBOM.html

Ty

slapha · ‎Sep 09, 2020

Only downside I see is it also disables auto-associate. Though I think we could live with that.

Do you know if this also prevents checkout/iteration of the Part as well for something with an image association with the build disabled?

I once worked at a place that disabled the build option for Image associated parts, this allowed us to associate multiple model representations post-release. Things like cables or tube/hose assemblies which would have identical part numbers but multiple model representations depending on where/how they were used. Essentially treated image association like content except that it could be used in the structure. Was wondering if this could be used instead in addition to the ability to prevent structure building in general for manually generated product structure.

Tdaugherty · ‎Sep 10, 2020

I'm not sure I totally understand your question. As far as I know, adding or subtracting associations will always iterate the WTpart. This functionality isn't dependent upon the EFBOM attribute.

We use the EFBOM functionality to control what lands in our WTpart structure. For example, we use quite a few pneumatic actuators. The actuators generally import as assemblies that contain the cylinder rod and body. The cylinder (assembly) needs to be on the BOM but we don't want the components (rod/body) on the BOM. The rod and body components would be set to EFBOM = Yes, prior to initial check in.

slapha · ‎Sep 14, 2020

Looks like this isn't what I'm looking for based on your clarification.
I guess I was looking more for prevent build rather than exclude from build.

I'm not looking to universally exclude a specific model from all BOMs, but rather control whether an assembly could build the BOM. It can be done other ways, but I thought there was an attribute that could drive it as well.

joe_morton · ‎Sep 14, 2020

Hi Ty,

How does this function work in Creo? Does it allow you to exclude a single instance from building in the BOM?

We have scenarios where in Creo, a part will be modeled more than once, typically to show two positions. It's difficult to verify that the WTPart structure is correct.

Tdaugherty · ‎Sep 15, 2020