Skip to main content

21 replies

Derbigdog
15-Moonstone
June 9, 2021

I tried to give it an honest evaluation, but found it extremely slow on my PC. I have an i7 8CPU @3.6 MHz, with 16 GB of ram and a SSD hard drive. Maybe they have done something in the last couple of months to speed it up. 

If I am not mistaken you have to buy both Maple and Maple Flow. 

Translate
12-Amethyst
June 11, 2021

From the Maple Flow purchase site, it appears that a copy of Maple is included with the price of Maple Flow:

1aidaho_0-1623429274781.png

May try the trial version, but initial reaction is the price could well be prohibitive, even if was better than MathCad.

Translate
23-Emerald I
June 10, 2021

Okay, I downloaded it; evaluation until 6/25.

 

Opened the tutorial to learn the basics.  It's going to be a steep learning curve!

 

In the tutorial (which I would think had been worked to perfection), typed a variable, followed by a colon (for colon/equal) then a number--got a red box "unhandled exception."  Typed the variable name in free space, below that typed name = , got "name = name.  (Great!)  Typed "name:6---got "unhandled exception!"  (If I double underline (to create a subscripted name the assignment works, but a simple variable name will not permit a numeric assignment.  And this is the tutorial page!

 

Not impressed so far.  And it's slow.

Translate
14-Alexandrite
June 10, 2021

I'm also evaluating Maple Flow

 

A name with no subscript: you need to type colon and equals (not just colon) to create a definition (the tutorials is in correct according to their tech support)

A name with a subscript: you need to type colon to create a definition

Translate
19-Tanzanite
June 10, 2021

I thought it would be interesting to do a side by side comparison of a relatively simple calculation, so I've compared my response to Fred's question about a weir -  see below.

WeirComparison.png

I didn't use units in Maple flow as I couldn't get the plot to work properly with them, though the individual calculations worked ok with them (it's likely that a more experienced Maple flow user would be able to get the plot done with units).  There are some syntax differences as might be expected - the above shows a difference in the way functions are defined.  

At present I find Mathcad easier to use -  but I've been using Mathcad for over 20 years, while I've been using Maple flow for one day!

 

Maple flow as above, but with symbolics and units:

FredsWeirMapleflow2.png

 

Alan

Translate
Derbigdog
15-Moonstone
June 10, 2021

Thanks for the test. I had trouble getting even that far. Even a few simple calculations took forever. 

I also am biased as I have used Mathcad for at least 25 years. But I did want to see if there was a viable alternative. Pricing is a problem with me as well.

Translate
24-Ruby IV
June 10, 2021

Oh, Mathcad is Mathcad, and Maple is Maple, and never the twain shall meet,

Till Earth and Sky stand presently at God's great Judgment Seat;

But there is neither Mathcad nor Maple, Border, nor Breed, nor Birth,

When two strong men stand face to face,

tho' they come from the ends of the earth!

Translate
23-Emerald IV
June 10, 2021

Hmm, 

Mathcad and Maple (MapleV version 4) have met, and quite successfully, in Mathcad 3 to 13, with Mathcad 11 as (in my view) the best.

 

Luc

Translate
24-Ruby IV
June 16, 2021

It was not a love marriage, but a marriage of convenience, which ended quickly.

Translate