Skip to main content
1-Visitor
March 4, 2013
Solved

MathCAD Units Help

  • March 4, 2013
  • 3 replies
  • 30496 views

I am using MathCAD Prime 2.0 for design calculations for a building I am engineering. I am fairly new to MathCAD, only learning a little about it in college. However, I am running into a units issue when calculating pounds per linear foot (lb/ft) to just pounds (a point load). I am taking 480 PLF * 4 ft, the feet should cancel out and you are left with just pounds. MathCAD is spitting out a lb*f, like the units for a moment. When I go to change the units to just pounds then it changes my units to (ft/s^2)*lb? Please explain to me what is going wrong here. See below for a screen shot:math+cad+question.jpg

Please note that the answer is correct, 1920 pounds is the right answer. Just the wrong units.

Thank you in advance,

Jon Recknagel | Structural Designer

Best answer by ptc-4992678

I just answered my own question. A "lbf"= a pound force. It seems like they could have just left it at "lb" we are all aware that pounds is a force. Just my opinon I guess. Thanks anyway.

3 replies

ptc-49926781-VisitorAuthorAnswer
1-Visitor
March 4, 2013

I just answered my own question. A "lbf"= a pound force. It seems like they could have just left it at "lb" we are all aware that pounds is a force. Just my opinon I guess. Thanks anyway.

19-Tanzanite
March 4, 2013

It seems like they could have just left it at "lb" we are all aware that pounds is a force.

The pound is a unit of mass, not force.

1-Visitor
March 4, 2013

I would disagree....Pounds (lb) is not a mass. Pounds is a force. F=mg, due to gravity.

10-Marble
March 4, 2013

The "lbf", pounds force is there to differentiate between pounds mass, which is just "lb". Something which matters greatly when doing dynamics, rather than statics.

25-Diamond I
March 4, 2013

You may want to check how the different units for Force per Length are defined in Mathcad

units.png

Maybe this thread is helpful http://communities.ptc.com/message/30166#30166

23-Emerald I
November 14, 2020

Careful!

You've run afoul of Mathcad's rule to use only the units required.  The definitions are valid if you proscribe the units

Fred_Kohlhepp_0-1605364321415.png