Skip to main content
20-Turquoise
March 28, 2013
Solved

Minimum value of the function.

  • March 28, 2013
  • 2 replies
  • 1835 views

Hello, Everyone.

Minimum value of f(x).PNG

Thanks in advance for your hint and help.

Best Regards.

Best answer by Raiko

Hello Loi Le,

try this sheet which uses the Minimize function

Raiko

2 replies

Raiko17-PeridotAnswer
17-Peridot
March 28, 2013

Hello Loi Le,

try this sheet which uses the Minimize function

Raiko

lvl10720-TurquoiseAuthor
20-Turquoise
March 28, 2013

Many thanks for your response, Raiko Milanovic.

Capture1.PNG

Best Regards,

Loi.

25-Diamond I
March 28, 2013

Its NOT a minimum - see my other post.

Its an "artificial" step at 0.5 because of Mathcads try making a function unique which is not unique.

25-Diamond I
March 28, 2013

Complex numbers and logarithms - a never ending story 😉

The graph you provided is only one of an infinite number of representations of your function f.

The reason is the second term which is the natural logarithm of a complex number with length 1. That logarithm of that kind of number is a complex number whose real part is zero (what is "rein imaginär" in English?).

But - the logarithm function is not unique over the complex numbers. The log of a complex number has infinite values, all of which have the same real part and the imaginary part differs by multiples of 2*pi. This, in your f(x), is then multiplied by sqrt(-3), making it a real number.

So in your function you can chose at any point x to add a multiple of 2*pi*sqrt(3) (the second log) and go on from there jumping from one leaf of the 4-dim log plane to another. Mathcad does this at x=1/2 because the arg function defaults to values from -pi to +pi. At x=1/2 the argument of the complex number in the second log would go beyond pi and so mathcad subtracts 2*pi - creating artificially the step you see in the graph. You may notice that the difference between the two "cusps" is exactly 2*pi*sqrt(3).

So if you forbid those kind of "jumps" and demand continous graphs, the answer to your question (minimum) is: its at x=0 and is pi/sqrt(3) plus any multiple of 2*pi*sqrt(3).

See below three (out of an infinite number of) continuous representations of your function:

minval1.png