Skip to main content
25-Diamond I
December 20, 2020
Question

New "speedometer"

  • December 20, 2020
  • 3 replies
  • 146 views

While I always criticised the ranking system (actually in my opinion we don't need any as we also don't need any kind of gamification) with the various stones where many people (including myself) could not tell the precise order and some confused the stone names with the name of the poster, its my feeling that now it got even worse.

While with the stones the criticism was that they don't communicate their meaning clear enough, the new "speedometer" does and even though I think that things got worse. While we could happily ignore the stones,  now functionality, comfort and usability are also impaired. The speedos are much too large and distracting and the whole page looks ugly and like a mess. Furthermore the graphics take up much too much space - especially vertical space (but also horizontally, resulting in the need for otherwise avoidable line breaks).

All this results in less information available per screen making more scrolling necessary which is a loss of comfort and usability without gaining anything worthwhile.

I really wish we could get rid of those speedos or get an option to hide them. @Jaime_Lee : I guess you won't drop those speedos just because of me thinking they are counterproductive, but is there a chance for an option in the personal preferences to hide them from view? Would be highly appreciated.

The best solution IMHO would be not to show the rank in the overview of threads but just show it with all the other information when you mouse-over the name.

 

Just look at the pic and compare space consumption without and with those speedos (it would even be better if we could get rid of the leftmost column of white space only!)

Werner_E_0-1608479136655.png

 

 

EDIT: Oh, I just noticed that it looks we a having speedos and still stones, too !!?? Only difference seems to be that the stone names now are not coloured as they used to be.

Werner_E_0-1608479347518.png

 

 

3 replies

Werner_E25-Diamond IAuthor
25-Diamond I
December 20, 2020

Heureka! Just found a way to block those speedometer pics using my ad-blocker.

Isn't it much more useful to see the topics of at least eight postings (more would even be better) on one screen of the overview page than being able to see hardly just two?

See and compare the  screenshots.

Werner_E_0-1608503626418.pngWerner_E_1-1608503652841.png

 

23-Emerald IV
December 21, 2020

@Werner_E wrote:

The best solution IMHO would be not to show the rank in the overview of threads but just show it with all the other information when you mouse-over the name.


+1

 

It looks like they've already been shrunk down some.  I think a little more is still needed.  Keep the total gauge height the same as the height of capital letters in the user names.

Werner_E25-Diamond IAuthor
25-Diamond I
December 21, 2020

I considered my posting as a valid "feedback" and so I posted it in the public "PTC Community Feedback" area. When I was looking for it to see if there are any answers, it was gone!! By chance (thanks to TomU who kudod my post and  so I got a link to the thread) I found it here as it obviously was moved without any notice in the private "PTC Community Refresh" area!

Why??? If TomU would not had kudod my posting I would had to assume that the thread was deleted!

23-Emerald IV
December 21, 2020

I am subscribed to 'PTC Community Refresh', so I did receive a message when @Jaime_Lee moved it:

 

TomU_0-1608583237714.png

 

She will have to tell us why she moved it here.