Skip to main content
24-Ruby IV
January 2, 2017
Question

Engineering sense of the correct answer in the calculations

  • January 2, 2017
  • 29 replies
  • 10853 views

I ask my students give correct answers in reports. One example

But I have seen in one German tram (constructed by good engineers) this table

Why 229 places for stay - not 230? The street car will break with 230 men?

In Mathcad Prime Minister we have

29 replies

23-Emerald IV
January 2, 2017

"The street car will break with 230 men?"

I guess it is to prevent the standing passengers from getting crushed, if you let more than 229 in....

I wonder what the personal space per person is that they calculated with.

In general, the (numeric) answer to a problem should not have more significant digits than the smallest number of siginificant digits of the input data.

If that is that what your '-1' setting is doing in Mathcad Prime Minister, then it should not be a '-1' setting on decimals, but rather a check box, that applies to most of the formats.

Success with the implementation.

Luc

24-Ruby IV
January 2, 2017

24-Ruby IV
January 2, 2017

Jules Verne was not an engineer - he was a lawyer with education! More about this problem http://twt.mpei.ac.ru/ochkov/MathLit.pdf