Skip to main content
16-Pearl
September 1, 2026
StickyQuestion

Mathcad Community Challenge September 2026 - Civil Engineering: Valencian Towers

  • September 1, 2026
  • 10 replies
  • 410 views

This month’s challenge has a civil engineering theme – actually, a bit of an ancient civil engineering theme related to my adopted home of Valencia, Spain. One of its most famous landmarks is the Torres de Serranos (Serranos Towers), one of the last remnants of its medieval wall:

Torres de Serranos in Valencia, Spain

In this challenge, you will perform some of the same calculations that master builder Pere Balaguer worked on in the 1390s. Except, of course, you have the benefit of modern software for engineering calculations. Specifically, you will perform analysis of the Gothic arch at its entrance:

Gothic Arch Gate Entrance to the Torres de Serranos

Dimensions and assumptions:

  • The arch is a classic three-hinged arch mechanism.
  • The span (horizontal width at the opening) is 6 meters.
  • The height from the spring line (where the arch transitions from vertical support and begins its inward curve) to the apex hinge is 4 meters.
  • It carries a uniform dead load from the floor above of 45 kN/m across the horizontal span.
  • The limestone blocks at the base of the arch have a structural thickness (depth into the wall) of 0.80 meters and a joint width along the arch curve of 0.50 meters. (This defines the joint contact area.)
  • The structure is symmetrical.

Challenge 1. Calculate the following:

  • the vertical reaction forces at each supporting wall.
  • the horizontal thrust pushing outward against the masonry buttresses.
  • the total resultant force that the foundations must withstand at the base.
  • the angle of the resultant force with respect to horizontal.

Challenge 2. Based on the results of the first challenge, calculate the following:

  • the parallel shear force acting directly across the plane of the mortar joint.
  • the average and maximum shear stress across the contact area. (Assume a parabolic distribution across the rectangular joint profile.)

Challenge 3. Use XY Plots or Chart Components to generate a bending moment diagram and/or a shear force diagram for the main gate pointed arch. Feel free to model the arch as either an approximated parabolic curve or a pointed Gothic layout.

Challenge 4. Can you calculate a geometrical factor of safety for the Gothic pointed arch of the main gate? Jacques Heyman’s thrust line theory may help in this situation.

 

Find the Mathcad Community Challenge Guidelines here!

10 replies

21-Topaz II
September 1, 2026

Hi Dave,

Can you explain the 0.5m and 0.8 m dimensions.  Which one runs on the plane of the arch and which one runs normal to arch plane?

Cheers

Terry

16-Pearl
September 2, 2026

Those two dimensions define the joint contact area for the shear stress calculation. They are the “horizontal” dimensions of the voussoir (limestone block) at the base of the arch (the springing line).

16-Pearl
September 15, 2026

Here are a couple more pictures hopefully to spark some interest. The first is a view of what the interior of the tower looks like. The second is a picture of its twin, the Torres de Quart, which was built about 50 years later on the western approach to the city. The damage on the exterior was from Napoleon’s forces in 1808 during the Peninsular War.

Interior of Torres de Serranos
Torres de Quart

I will also start posting some solutions which might help people get started.

16-Pearl
September 15, 2026
21-Topaz II
September 18, 2026

Hi,

Here is my two cents worth.  All 28 pages due to the horrendously sized solve block.

Usually the old champions used to get a copy of Prime each year.  I am retired so cannot afford Prime each year and relied on the freebee.  This is made in the 30 day trial period before express.  Will likely be my last post.

 

Cheers

Terry 

RantEng
14-Alexandrite
September 25, 2026

I feel your pain but have a possible solution.  I’ve used Mathcad since version 1.x something (1986 ish).  Also retired and I’ve met personally with PTC execs.  They all agree that, yes, it would be a good idea to do something for retired heroes. But, no, nobody is really interested in championing that cauise.

What I have done, is worked with my previous employer.  A company's floating license allows 5 home licenses for each floating license.  These are seldom used.  So, they keep me working with a home license now that I’m retired. 

For forty years, this has been my thinking tool.  First thing I did each day was open my email and Mathcad.  I have retired but haven’t stopped thinking.  Hope you have a good relationship you can leverage.

 

Bob

Robert (Bob) Adams
DJNewman
19-Tanzanite
September 28, 2026

FYI, the Community management team told me that they plan to distribute software for all champions in October, and that’s something new they’re doing. (As opposed to before, where each champion or group of champions has a unique distribution date.)

PTC Marketer for Creo and Mathcad. I run their YouTube channels, some Creo campaigns, and all Mathcad campaigns and communications.
16-Pearl
September 23, 2026

With one week left to go, here are the calculations related to challenge 2. This might help people approach challenges 3 and 4. Good luck!

 

21-Topaz II
September 26, 2026

Hi All,

Late in the month but a second submission.  This one shows the power of Prime to do Finite Element Analysis (FEM) of the arch with a trial and error approach.

Cheers

Terry

23-Emerald I
September 28, 2026
Prime 4 Express