Configuration Management of Released state parent models in Windchill. Cannot regenerate released parent models in Creo if child part was revised.
- September 5, 2014
- 9 replies
- 6688 views
Hi we're currently reviewing our model change management process and need to know what is good industry standard best practice w.r.t. the following example(Please refer to pdf example). For example let say a Creo part on a indent level 3(BN3 Rev C) needs to change. The part is interchangeable in all "where used" parent models.Hence only revision change to this part is needed. In Windchill PDM Link the part will get revised( to BN3 rev D) and checked out of Windchill to make appropriate changes in Creo session. After changes is made the part gets checked into Windchill again and promoted to a Released state.
My question is how does companies handle the parent CAD models in the Creo/Windchill environment for a child revision example as explained above? For instance if I open a Released parent model in Creo(lets say Model BN4 RevA) the 'As stored model' will be opened in Creo showing the old BN3 Rev C child model. The BN4 model can not be regenerated since it is kept in a Released state. The only way to capture the BN3 Rev D model change is to revise the BN4 parent model to allow model to regenerate. To capture the BN3 Rev D change in all the 'Where Used" parent models all higher level parent models needs to be revised so as to be put into In-Work state to allow Creo regenerate to run. We call this process Revision Tumbling. This creates a massive administrative nightmare due to all the drawings that needs to get signed off again. So how does other companies handle this? According to configuration Management principles when a changed is made on lower level model, that does not effect interchangeability,a company should only have to revise that specific model. No other revision changes of higher level parents should have to happen. Do companies except that higher level parent drawing illustrations of BN3 will be out of date?
My 2nd question relates to how does companies manage Windchill publishing of all the parent models after the BN3 Rev C change. Our company is setup to publish BN3 Rev C on promotion to Released state. This will update the BN3 vieweable but all the parent vieweable models will still be out of date. What is the best method to use to ensure all parent assemblies vieweables are up kept up to date? Can we use positioning assembly option in Windchill better? We need some kins of automated solution to keep our illustrations current as best possible
Thanks for any inputs on this duscussion.

