Skip to main content
A
AS_1108123910-Marble
10-Marble
July 31, 2024
Solved

Generic and Family Table instances should be in Same version/Revision

  • July 31, 2024
  • 4 replies
  • 1136 views

Version: Windchill 12.1

 

Use Case: Creating family table instance for existing solidworks generic sldprt. existing Generic have revision B.1, Family table created with Revision A.1


Description:

Hi Community,
want to maintain the Revision for Generic and Family table instances with same revision,
Here one of user take generic Cad part of solidworks which existed in C.1 version and user created family table instance for that CAD Part and checked in new family table was created as A.1 version.
this there is mismatch of parent generic CAD and Family table instance here. So we wanted to maintain same version of generic CAD part in family table instance CAD part.
Is it possible in Windchill? this need any customization? or any preference management OOTB options available?
please help.

Best answer by DmitryC

There is a setting in Windchill Preference Management that defines the initial revision from SolidWorks custom properties:

DmitryC_2-1723091781693.png

 

On top of that, we have a custom new configuration macro in Solidworks that creates new configurations with an option to define the revision (it just creates the appropriate custom property):

DmitryC_3-1723092110362.png

 

We also have a custom SolidWorks Add-in. One of the things that this add-in does - it deletes this custom property when the new instance is created in Windchill (so things won't get messed up if you do a save-as).

4 replies

avillanueva
23-Emerald I
avillanueva23-Emerald I
23-Emerald I
July 31, 2024

This is certainly not OOTB nor is there a preference to control this. This would your organizations business rule and should be handled via a change process or release process. There are a number of preferences for collectors (like Revise collector) that you should use if you want to make it less mistake proof to avoid not including instances on revise for example. Your rule is not a bad one and I think one that most companies follow. Its just that not all will so its not forced upon all users that its the only way to managed them.

You can customize a listener to fix the revision on instances to match the generic when creating them later. You also have the option before checking to bump a newly created instance of an EPMDocument to a higher revision but not once its been fully checked in.

    B
    23-Emerald III
    BenLoosli23-Emerald III
    23-Emerald III
    July 31, 2024

    By default all new objects are created at version A.1. This can be changed through OIR rules are manually. 

    This is one reason why I do not revise family table parts, even when adding new instances. All of our family table parts are at revision A. These parts are also controlled by being in a Library and only the system admins have librarian privileges to edit them.

    Depending on how many you have it may be just as easy to revise the ones that are not at the same revision as the generic to that revision.

     

      D
      DmitryC14-AlexandriteAnswer
      14-Alexandrite
      August 8, 2024

      There is a setting in Windchill Preference Management that defines the initial revision from SolidWorks custom properties:

      DmitryC_2-1723091781693.png

       

      On top of that, we have a custom new configuration macro in Solidworks that creates new configurations with an option to define the revision (it just creates the appropriate custom property):

      DmitryC_3-1723092110362.png

       

      We also have a custom SolidWorks Add-in. One of the things that this add-in does - it deletes this custom property when the new instance is created in Windchill (so things won't get messed up if you do a save-as).

      Catalina
      CatalinaCommunity Manager
      Community Moderator
      August 12, 2024

      Hi @AS_11081239,


      I wanted to see if you got the help you needed.


      If so, please mark the appropriate reply as the Accepted Solution. It will help other members who may have the same question.
      Please note that industry experts also review the replies and may eventually accept one of them as solution on your behalf.
      Of course, if you have more to share on your issue, please pursue the conversation.

      Thanks,

      Catalina | PTC Community Moderator
        Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement