Skip to main content
1-Visitor
September 6, 2013
Question

Assembly mode cuts and chamfers in Creo 2 M50

  • September 6, 2013
  • 14 replies
  • 7012 views

I am looking to create several cuts and thenbreak the edges with a chamfer in assy mode.


I created the cuts and select the edges and the chamfer icon is greyed out.


Did we loose functionality in Creo? (I just updated from WF4)

14 replies

1-Visitor
June 26, 2015

I complained to the guys at PTC LIVE GLOBAL 2015.  I am often making band-aids for such features.   Just this week I had a weldment that I put a square o-ring groove into, It sure would have been nice to put a round in each of the grooves.  I got lazy and did not want to create all the surfaces and solidify them.....I just put a note on the drawing and grumbled to my cube mate something nice about PTC.

1-Visitor
February 23, 2018

i made a sketch in creo 4.0 & for every corner i have to mentioned the corner radius/chamfer value. it really consuming a lot of time. 

what is the simple way to do in minimum step.

17-Peridot
February 23, 2018

It seems to me that family tables lend themselves greatly to manage post-processed parts within next-level assemblies.

 

I am also a fan of assembly Merge operations if you can manage phantoms on your BOM and/or don't have objections to external relations. 

 

I am not a -big- fan of either solution though.  On the fly I would go for a simple sweep or revolve cut to solve the problem.

 

I will cycle through these options depending on the ultimate task at hand.

 

Also look into welding... -that- was PTC's answer to adding material!

And no answer for raw assembly level deformation by tonnage! 

 

Patriot_1776
22-Sapphire II
February 23, 2018

It seems I agree with all here in that we should be able to add material (welds) and make simple things like chamfers and rounds at the assy level.  Honestly, why not have access to ALL the modeling features, and then if we make something that can't be manufactured, well, that's on us as it always is here in the real world.

 

Our spacecraft uses composites (carbon fiber), and there are times 2 parts are joined at assembly with additional layers of C/F, and these can be very complex shapes.  Also, sometimes after adding this extra material at assembly, a final finishing cut is done on the assy as a whole, to get the desired aero shape.   How are we supposed to do that easily if we can't freely add or subtract material????

 

Ok, if it needs to be a little more $$ in the "Advanced Assy" option, we're willing to pay it..  you listening PTC?