Skip to main content
1-Visitor
May 23, 2017
Solved

U-substitution

hello all,

i am trying to get my head around integration by substitution.

in a simple case of the integrand (x-1)/2 dx  I know the answer is (x^2/4)-(x/2).

if I try to do this by substitution, I get a bit lost.

ive gone as follows:

u= x-1

du=1*dx

dx=du

(u/2)du

(u^2)/4

(x-1)^2/4

(x^2-2x+1)/4

obviously this is not correct. Does anyone know what I'm doing wrong?

‌

19-Tanzanite
May 23, 2017

You have done it correctly!  The apparent difference is because an indefinite integral is only defined to within an arbitrary constant.  The two forms you show are the same to within an arbitrary constant.

Alan

4 replies

19-Tanzanite
May 23, 2017

You have done it correctly!  The apparent difference is because an indefinite integral is only defined to within an arbitrary constant.  The two forms you show are the same to within an arbitrary constant.

Alan

Translate
awibroe1-VisitorAuthor
1-Visitor
May 23, 2017

‌Alan,

thanks for that, interesting!

so if I make the original integral limited between 2 and 4 I believe the end result ends up being 2. When doing this for the substitution method, the limits I believe become 1 and 3 noting that my I value is x-1. This produces an answer of 1 not 2?

andy

Translate
23-Emerald I
May 23, 2017

Looks like the same answer to me!

Translate
awibroe1-VisitorAuthor
1-Visitor
May 23, 2017

I know what I have done wrong. Yes Fred it is indeed correct.

Fascinating stuff!

Andy

Translate